Reached For

Evidence index · Skillets

Skillets, according to home cooks

Only claims about skillets made by people we have grounds to call home cooks. The unrestricted skillets evidence is on the skillets page.

home cooks is who the advice is aimed at.

12 people on record as home cooks make 439 quoted claims about skillets across 39 sources. Membership is recorded with its own evidence — for a person by the trait they are on record holding, for a community by the source it was said in — and authority is scoped to skillets rather than to fame.

Which skillets do home cooks recommend?

Endorsements and objections about skillets from home cooks, together, strongest evidence first. There are 33 with evidence; the 15 with the most independent voices are below, and every one is in the claim search.

Lodge cast iron skillet

Smithey cast iron skillet

Matfer carbon steel pan

3:31 supports Lisa of America's Test Kitchen Cookware Reviewer
I loved this pan so much that when I was testing it, before I was even done, I was like, "I want this pan," and I ordered one for myself, which I never do. So I've had mine for several years and I love it. I cook in it all the time.

durability Owns it Are Carbon Steel Pans Really The Best? | Gear Heads

1:30 supports Lisa of America's Test Kitchen Cookware Reviewer
We tested eight pans, and believe me, they were not all good. Some of them were real clunky, some really just never took to seasoning. They had sides that were too high, really off in balance. They just were not worth it. This one's our favorite. It's Matfer Bourgeat 11 7/8-inch Black Steel Frying Pan.

best in class Tested it Are Carbon Steel Pans Really The Best? | Gear Heads

Field cast iron skillet

De Buyer carbon steel pan

8:03 supportsobjects Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
de Buyer Mineral B Pro is heavier and heats slower than Strata, but it didn't warp, made minimal noise, and retained heat longer than any other carbon steel pan I tested.

Four judgements rest on this sentence:

Don’t Buy Induction Cookware Until You Watch This (13 Brands Tested)

Finex cast iron skillet

8:36 supports Luis J. speaking on Luis J. Cast Iron Cooking Cookware Reviewer
so overall this number 10 has done wonderful it's held up seasoning really well it's cooked really well besides that small little defect with my time that it tends to warp I've had no issues and uh as you know as I said it cooked my breakfast beautifully and I'm happy with it so two years it's done great I'm happy and…

best in class Owns it Cast Iron Wednesday: 2 Year Review of the Finex No. 10 Skillet

Cites seasoning durability

2:03 supports Luis J. speaking on Luis J. Cast Iron Cooking Cookware Reviewer
okay guys so now let's just talk about the cooking performance of this Skillet of the finex number 10 and I'm not disappointed because I've done a lot of things I've done gravies I've done um like uh searing a steak and then making a sauce with deglazing using wine beef stock or chicken stock you know and things like…

performance Owns it Cast Iron Wednesday: 2 Year Review of the Finex No. 10 Skillet

Cites acid resistance, heat retention, seasoning durability, versatility

Stargazer cast iron skillet

0:36 supports Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer earns commission on this
Overall, it cooks as well or better than any cast iron I've tested.

best in class Tested it Stargazer Cast Iron Review: Is This $145 Skillet Better Than a $30 Lodge?

Prudent Reviews earns commission on this. Stated in the source: “Those are affiliate links so I will earn a commission if you click and buy but at no extra cost to you.” Kept and labelled rather than dropped: a paid endorsement is still evidence, and you should be the one to decide what it is worth.

Lodge enameled cast iron Dutch oven

0:35 supports Uncle Scott speaking on Uncle Scott's Kitchen Beginners earns commission on this
I'm going to give this guy a 90% thumbs up on the pro side.

recommendation Tested it NEW: Lodge USA Enamel Review with cooking & Staub/Le Creuset comparison!

Cites appearance, country of manufacture

Uncle Scott earns commission on this. Stated in the source: “USK currently has affiliate links and/or influencer links with Amazon, Falk, De Buyer, Thermoworks, Breville, Lodge, Smithey and others.” Kept and labelled rather than dropped: a paid endorsement is still evidence, and you should be the one to decide what it is worth.

But I am glad I have one of them in my Battery Deuisine now. They crank out a ton of delicious food. I think they have a nice look and design. They're made in America.
Um, I really like mine. I'm giving it a 90% thumbs up.
1:05 supports Uncle Scott speaking on Uncle Scott's Kitchen Beginners earns commission on this
This lodge is pushing 15 pounds. Holy cow, that is a sturdy piece of cookware.

handling Tested it NEW: Lodge USA Enamel Review with cooking & Staub/Le Creuset comparison!

Cites weight

Uncle Scott earns commission on this. Stated in the source: “USK currently has affiliate links and/or influencer links with Amazon, Falk, De Buyer, Thermoworks, Breville, Lodge, Smithey and others.” Kept and labelled rather than dropped: a paid endorsement is still evidence, and you should be the one to decide what it is worth.

0:35 supports Uncle Scott speaking on Uncle Scott's Kitchen Beginners earns commission on this
First is realworld cooking performance. It has turned out a ton of delicious food and that is the most important factor.

performance Tested it NEW: Lodge USA Enamel Review with cooking & Staub/Le Creuset comparison!

Cites heat retention

Uncle Scott earns commission on this. Stated in the source: “USK currently has affiliate links and/or influencer links with Amazon, Falk, De Buyer, Thermoworks, Breville, Lodge, Smithey and others.” Kept and labelled rather than dropped: a paid endorsement is still evidence, and you should be the one to decide what it is worth.

it is nice to see the Lodge USA made Dutch oven competing nicely with the stove and I think this beef bergen was equally delicious in both.
the oil temperature only dropped down to about 342. So that is not much of a drop in temperature at all. And then of course it rebounded on up.
So there's a lot of heat trapped in that thermal mass of a lodge and I think it did a great job.
It's winter time in Utah at the moment and I've been using these lodges to crank out some shephardd's pies and they've turned out fantastically.

Anolon EverLast N2

6:02 supports Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
The water from the Misen and Anolon came out completely clear, but the water from Strata was cloudy with a yellow tint, which means bits of the seasoning layer were breaking down and leaching into the liquid.

performance Tested it Which “Forever Nonstick” Pan Is the Best? I Tested Them All

Cites flavour impact, heat control, heating speed, non-stick surface

Anolon was by far the fastest to heat, but that means it's also very easy to overheat.
When I preheated it slower, it worked fine.
Next, I cut the fat in half, using just a half teaspoon of oil and 2 g of butter. Again, all three pans handled it without sticking.
Then I tested pancakes with a light layer of butter. Misen and Anolon released cleanly, but Strata had some slight sticking.
Misen and Anolon were both impressively nonstick right out of the box, and they've stayed that way for months.
To be totally honest with you, this was one of the toughest reviews I've ever done because all three pans perform really well, and they're all priced pretty much the same.
6:32 objects Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
Anolon was by far the fastest to heat, but that means it's also very easy to overheat. A few times during testing, I had to stop, open a window, and start over because the pan started smoking before I could even add food.

performance Tested it Which “Forever Nonstick” Pan Is the Best? I Tested Them All

Cites heat control (against), heat retention (against), non-stick surface (against)

They're not optimized for heat retention like thicker carbon steel or cast iron pans, but within this group, Strata held its temperature the best by about 10°.
The only issue was with Anolon on my first try. Because it heats so quickly, the pan got way too hot and the egg stuck.
Finally, I cooked pancakes with no fat at all. Anolon had just a little sticking, but I was able to flip the pancake without breaking it.
They're not as slick as a brand-new Teflon pan, but if you don't overheat them and you use a little oil or butter, food won't stick.
The only times I've had issues were when I overheated them.

Made In skillet

7:01 supportsobjects Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
In my heat tests, the center heated fairly quickly, but there was a 130° difference between the center and the edge after 2 minutes of heating, which was the second largest gap in the group.

Two judgements rest on this sentence:

I Tested Every Cast Iron Skillet, These Are the Best & Worst

The smooth surface also performed extremely well in the egg test. The egg released immediately and slid around the pan with no sticking and the pour spouts didn't drip at all.
Made In has my favorite handle of the group, and it cooks extremely well once it's fully preheated.

Victoria skillet

Victoria Signature Series

Mauviel M'Steel carbon steel frying pan

6:38 supports Uncle Scott speaking on Uncle Scott's Kitchen Beginners earns commission on this
I gotta say I really like this thing

performance Tested it Mauviel M'Steel Pan Seasoning and Cooking In-Depth

Cites build quality, handle, non-stick surface, searing and crust, seasoning durability

Uncle Scott earns commission on this. Stated in the source: “*Current Mauviel Prices:* htps://amzn.to/2PQieFW (Uncle Scott's affiliate link)” Kept and labelled rather than dropped: a paid endorsement is still evidence, and you should be the one to decide what it is worth.

I think we did a pretty good job on this one
I started out on my big powerful burner and they got good browning on both sides
once I got that beeswax off of there though it could just fine
these pans they're very heavy they're solid you've got strong handles good quality
you can see how much coloration and seasoning has occurred just in that slight amount of cooking just in one day
2:37 objects Uncle Scott speaking on Uncle Scott's Kitchen Beginners earns commission on this
no I finally removed all the beeswax but it ended up taking an entire roll of paper towels five kettles of boiling water and scalding most of my digital

performance Tested it Mauviel M'Steel Pan Seasoning and Cooking In-Depth

Cites maintenance (against)

Uncle Scott earns commission on this. Stated in the source: “*Current Mauviel Prices:* htps://amzn.to/2PQieFW (Uncle Scott's affiliate link)” Kept and labelled rather than dropped: a paid endorsement is still evidence, and you should be the one to decide what it is worth.

the Mafia vote was definitely harder to give the initial cleaning to it had a lot of beeswax on it
4:08 objects Uncle Scott speaking on Uncle Scott's Kitchen Beginners earns commission on this
the pan is so big and heavy that my wife couldn't do it she had to use two hands

handling Tested it Mauviel M'Steel Pan Seasoning and Cooking In-Depth

Cites weight (against)

Uncle Scott earns commission on this. Stated in the source: “*Current Mauviel Prices:* htps://amzn.to/2PQieFW (Uncle Scott's affiliate link)” Kept and labelled rather than dropped: a paid endorsement is still evidence, and you should be the one to decide what it is worth.

Griswold number 10 skillet

12:33 objects Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
After about 85 years of use, the seasoning isn't perfectly even, and there are some small pits and marks in the surface, so that likely played a role.

durability Tested it I Tested Every Cast Iron Skillet, These Are the Best & Worst

Cites surface finish (against), seasoning durability (against), warp resistance (against)

This skillet was already slightly warped when I bought it, which is one of the risks with vintage cookware. After the warp test, it got worse and the pan wobbled and spun on the cook top.
12:33 objects Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
Because of that, it was the fastest skillet to heat, but it also had the biggest temperature difference between the center and the edge and the lowest heat retention in the group.

performance Tested it I Tested Every Cast Iron Skillet, These Are the Best & Worst

Cites even heating (against), heat retention (against), non-stick surface (against)

The cooking surface on this Griswold is extremely smooth. But surprisingly, it had the worst result in my egg test. I had to work the spatula underneath the egg to release it, and a small amount stuck.

Matfer copper frying pan

What do home cooks say about skillets in general?

Not a recommendation for a specific product: technique, materials and what to look for in skillets. Citable on its own terms. There are 101 of them; the 40 with the strongest evidence are below.

3:31 supports Christopher Scott Buy It For Life Enthusiasts
but this is great for like I love doing stir fries in this I love doing searing steaks in this is great

use-case fit Owns it If I Started Over, I'd Only Buy These Pots & Pans

Cites heat retention, searing and crust

cast iron if I'm going to seirus steak I'm probably going to do it in a cast iron pan
this cast iron I particularly love to use for frittatas it's the perfect depth it holds the heat really well and it Cooks the frittatas perfectly like a nice thick frittata so I do love that small 8 in
I love to use cast iron on open fire on the grill on the smoker there's really nothing better for open fire than cast iron and Searing a steak
but like I mentioned in the beginning of this video a very well-made 5 to S ply stainless steel pan will SE a steak very well also
I'd go with the big cast iron because it's so useful for so many things on the fire
I'd go with the big cast iron because it's so useful for so many things on the fire
3:38 supports Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
Its ability to hold temperature so stable is why cast iron is the ultimate cookware for searing.

best in class Tested it Stainless Steel vs. Cast Iron Cookware: 7 Key Differences & When to Use Each

Cites heat retention, searing and crust, surface finish, versatility

Stainless steel is the ultimate all-purpose cookware. You can use it to sear meat and fish, saute vegetables, boil pasta, simmer sauces, and much more.
Stainless steel is also the best type of cookware for pan sauces. Since it's uncoated, cooking meat in a stainless steel pan creates fond, which is the brown stuck-on bits of concentrated meat flavor at the bottom of the pan.
1:30 supports Lisa of America's Test Kitchen Cookware Reviewer
the non-stick pans that you buy are gonna gradually become less and less non-stick. So the great steering that you can get in this pan and its ability to become more and more naturally non-stick makes this a favorite here at The Test Kitchen. All of our Test Cooks love this pan and we love to use it. In fact, we kind…

best in class Uses it professionally Are Carbon Steel Pans Really The Best? | Gear Heads

Cites coating durability, heat retention, maintenance, non-stick surface, versatility

As we saw with the burgers, the carbon steel pan has certain traits that really make it a great all-around pan. It definitely has that nice heat retention and heat transfer of a cast iron pan. It has that nice release of a non-stick pan. This is a great all-around pan, does almost anything you want it to do, it's…
0:30 supports Lisa of America's Test Kitchen Cookware Reviewer
Retains a lot of the properties that we love in cast iron, this ability to retain heat and really put a nice sear on food, but it's much easier to handle.

performance Owns it Are Carbon Steel Pans Really The Best? | Gear Heads

Cites ergonomics, heat control, safety, ease of cleaning, even heating, heat retention, non-stick surface

Other secret of this pan is its ability to become naturally non-stick. So the smooth grain of this takes to seasoning a little faster than cast iron and it becomes very rapidly non-stick when you season it. And you can cook in it with just a little bit of fat, and food will just come right out. So if you're really…
Stainless steel or, in particular, a fully clad pan where there are layers of stainless steel, aluminum, and stainless steel is really known for its ability to make even, uniform heat. The aluminum transmits heat very quickly, stainless steel much more slowly. The stainless retains it so it spreads, and you get this…
In the carbon steel, I think we got the sort of Goldilocks moment. You get this really beautiful golden brown crust that is deeply brown, and nice, and crusty. Inside is nice and pink. And you really get this nice contrast between the brown crust and the cooked interior that is nice and juicy. So I thought it was a…
When we were done, there was almost nothing in the pan. It was just, I wipe it out, rinse it out, and we're good to go.
1:00 supports Christopher Scott Buy It For Life Enthusiasts
there's three ply there's five ply there's seven ply Alloys that are stainless steel with titanium to make them stronger and last longer and look better for a longer time period

durability Owns it If I Started Over, I'd Only Buy These Pots & Pans

Cites appearance, durability

Owned 9 years

but this pan has been a Workhorse I think this is a 14inch I've had this pan for 9 years I don't even know the brand of this one but I I think I bought this one in HomeGoods or something like that a long long time ago
3:38 supports Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
Heat retention comes in handy when you’re entertaining. You can turn the burner off, and the food will stay warm while you prepare the rest of the meal.

use-case fit Tested it Stainless Steel vs. Cast Iron Cookware: 7 Key Differences & When to Use Each

Cites acid resistance, heat control, heating speed, heat retention, non-stick surface, versatility, weight

Because it’s so thick and heavy and holds heat well, it’s the better option for searing steaks, pork chops, chicken, and other meats.
It’s also better for cooking eggs, pancakes and other delicate ingredients. When cast iron is well seasoned it performs similarly to a non-stick pan.
Lastly, cast iron is ideal for roasting, baking, and frying because it heats up gradually and maintains a consistent temperature over long periods. Because it heats slowly, you’re less likely to burn food.
Stainless steel is more of a go-to everyday type of cookware. It heats fast and evenly and you can use it to cook any type of food, including tomato sauces, soup, and other acidic and liquid heavy meals.
2:38 supports Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
Stainless steel pans, especially ones with fully-clad construction, distribute heat more evenly than cast iron pans.

performance Tested it Stainless Steel vs. Cast Iron Cookware: 7 Key Differences & When to Use Each

Cites acid resistance, even heating, heat conduction, heat control, heating speed, heat retention, non-stick surface, versatility

But, since stainless steel pans are made with a highly conductive aluminum or copper core, they heat up fast and evenly.
The water in the stainless steel pan started boiling after 2 minutes and 55 seconds, and the water in the cast iron pan started boiling after 3 minutes and 34 seconds.
Cast iron may not heat up as fast or evenly as stainless steel, but due to its thick construction, it has far superior heat retention.
Don’t get me wrong, stainless steel pans, especially good quality fully clad pans, retain heat well, but not at the same level as cast iron.
After ten minutes, the water in the cast iron pan was 104 degrees Fahrenheit and the water in the stainless steel pans was only 96 degrees Fahrenheit.
Because it’s nonreactive and heats evenly, you can cook anything and perform any cooking technique.
Cast iron is also versatile - you can use it searing, roasting, sauteing, frying, baking, and cooking eggs.
But if you do it the right way, it also creates a slick surface that makes it easy to cook eggs and other delicate foods without sticking.
Because it responds to temperature changes quicker, you have more control over the results.
8:33 supports Hannah of America's Test Kitchen Buy It For Life Enthusiasts
First, a broad cooking surface. We preferred pans that offered at least 10 inches of flat cooking surface.

recommendation Tested it Cast Iron vs Enameled Cast Iron: Which is Better? | Gear Heads

Cites handle, shape and form, size and capacity

That extra height is really necessary for containing hot oil and food, such as when frying donuts and shallow frying chicken.
but we preferred those with wide broad loops that we could really hang onto, especially when wearing oven mitts
Generally though, we recommend buying a 12 inch skillet if you can. It's always good to have the option of a bigger pan for recipes of different sizes
5:32 objects Hannah of America's Test Kitchen Buy It For Life Enthusiasts
The enamel coating can sometimes heat and expand and retract at different rates, which can lead to cracking, an issue called crazing.

reliability Tested it Cast Iron vs Enameled Cast Iron: Which is Better? | Gear Heads

Cites crazing (against), non-stick surface (against)

While some manufacturers claim their pans will do this and become more non-stick with use, in our hands-on testing experience, we found that not to be the case.
3:01 supports Hannah of America's Test Kitchen Buy It For Life Enthusiasts
Artisan makers often cast their to have thinner sides, but a thicker bottom which cuts down on the total weight of the pan, but keeps that heat retention capability.

performance Tested it Cast Iron vs Enameled Cast Iron: Which is Better? | Gear Heads

Cites heat retention, non-stick surface, surface finish, weight

Most artisan makers will also take the time to hand polish their pan surface, which makes it naturally non-stick much faster than a mass produced pan.
2:01 supports Hannah of America's Test Kitchen Buy It For Life Enthusiasts
Generally being a single piece of metal also makes these skillets very sturdy.

durability Tested it Cast Iron vs Enameled Cast Iron: Which is Better? | Gear Heads

Cites build quality, coating, durability, ease of cleaning, maintenance, rust resistance

These cast iron pans start out like traditional cast iron, but then they're coated in a glass like vitreous glaze that seals the pan from air and moisture that could cause rust
their enamel coating makes enamel cast iron pans virtually maintenance free. You never have to season them and you can soak, use soap and scrub as much as you'd like.
Okay, that is my buying guide for these wonderful lifetime pans.
0:30 supports Hannah of America's Test Kitchen Buy It For Life Enthusiasts
In terms of cooking, there's very little these pans can't do.

performance Tested it Cast Iron vs Enameled Cast Iron: Which is Better? | Gear Heads

Cites even heating, heat conduction, heat retention, searing and crust, versatility

Its superpower is that it can retain and conduct plenty of heat for deep browning of food.
like regular cast iron, these pans have excellent heat retention, so they'll sear, fry and braise well maintaining the heat you want without undesirable temperature dips as food is added or flipped
Though all of these are gonna sear a great steak.
A thick heavy pan has the mass and density to hold more heat than a thinner pan does, and once preheated will cook more evenly than a thinner and lighter pan
0:00 supports Hannah of America's Test Kitchen Buy It For Life Enthusiasts
Cast iron skillets are one of the most versatile pieces of cookware you can buy since they work on the stove top in the oven, even on the grill.

use-case fit Tested it Cast Iron vs Enameled Cast Iron: Which is Better? | Gear Heads

Cites acid resistance, induction compatible, maintenance, oven safe, stovetop compatibility, versatility

Best of all, you can cook almost anything, even acidic foods that need to be simmered for a long time like a tomato sauce because the enamel seals the cast iron making the pan rust proof and non-reactive.
While both regular and enameled cast iron pans are induction compatible, the smoother enameled bottoms can be a little gentler on glass cooktops
Enameled is for the person that never wants to think about seasoning their pan. Enamel doesn't need it.
0:00 supports Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
Most cast iron skillets today come pre-seasoned so you can start cooking right away

performance You've Been Lied To About Cast Iron Cookware

Cites acid resistance, ease of cleaning, even heating, heat retention, maintenance, non-stick surface, rust resistance, seasoning durability

When you do need to season it, all you have to do is clean it, dry it, rub it with a thin layer of oil, and bake it in the oven. Although the baking portion takes an hour or so, the actual work you need to do takes less than 5 minutes. It’s not a big deal and it’s not difficult
But the reality is that seasoning isn't just oil; it's polymerized oil that's been bonded to the cast iron. It's hard and tough and as long as the dish soap doesn't contain lye or sodium hydroxide, a few drops won't hurt
I always recommend using a chainmail to clean cast iron, but if you cooked an especially messy meal and chainmail is not doing the trick, mild dish soap is okay
As you can see, the soap didn’t impact the seasoning at all
But flavoring food with a small amount of acidic ingredients, such as a splash of wine, vinegar, or lemon juice, won't cause any issues
If you're not cooking highly acidic foods for a long time, like over 30 minutes, the seasoning should be fine
To prove this point, I squeezed a whole lemon into this cast iron pan and let it simmer for about 4 minutes. After removing the lemon juice and wiping the skillet, you can see that the seasoning wasn't affected at all
One of the reasons I love cast iron is that it retains heat exceptionally well
Once it's fully preheated, it retains heat well, so your food will cook evenly
That may be true, but in my experience, this step is completely unnecessary. If the skillet is well-seasoned and you dry it thoroughly, it shouldn’t rust, and you don't need to oil it after each use
1:00 supports Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
Carbon steel, with its lower carbon content, is more pliable. In other words, it can be bent and shaped without cracking.

durability Carbon Steel Pans EXPLAINED (What They Don’t Tell You)

Cites acid resistance, durability, ease of cleaning, flexibility, maintenance, scratch resistance, seasoning durability

For acidic foods, stainless steel and enameled cast iron are better options since there's no seasoning to damage and those materials are non-reactive.
But you don't need to do it often and after you do it once, you realize how easy it is.
In my experience, mild dish soap does no harm.
One of the biggest advantages of carbon steel is its durability. It won't crack or break if you drop it, which can happen with cast iron.
And there's no coating or enamel that can wear down or chip.
You can use metal utensils and even cut food in it, although I try to avoid that because the sharp edge will scratch the seasoning.
It’s one of the rare products that gets better with age. The more you use it, the better the seasoning develops.
1:00 objects Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
The higher carbon in cast iron makes it harder but also more brittle. That's why cast iron has such thick walls - thinner walls would be prone to cracking.

durability Owns it Carbon Steel Pans EXPLAINED (What They Don’t Tell You)

Cites acid resistance (against), dishwasher safe (against), durability (against), maintenance (against), rust resistance (against), scratch resistance (against), seasoning durability (against), warp resistance (against)

The one major limitation with carbon steel pans is acidic foods. A squeeze of lemon or a splash of wine won’t hurt, but prolonged exposure to acidic foods, like tomato sauce, will strip the layer of seasoning right off the looking surface.
Bare cast iron pans have this same issue.
Carbon steel consists primarily of iron, which rusts when exposed to water and air.
The fact that you need to season carbon steel pans may seem like a major downside, and for some, it's a deal-breaker.
The two rules that I do highly recommend following are, one, don’t put carbon steel pans in the dishwasher. The hot water, steam, and dish detergent will ruin the seasoning.
And two, always dry your pans completely after washing them. Even a well-seasoned pan can rust if moisture is left on it for long periods.
if you notice tiny black bits on your food when you cook with carbon steel, or if you wipe the pan with a paper towel and the paper towel turns black, that's a sign that you need to deep clean your pan. Those black bits are either tiny pieces of the seasoning flaking, burnt food, or both.
The one thing you need to be cautious about is warping. If you expose it to drastic temperature changes, like rinsing it under cold water when it's piping hot, the metal can expand and contract unevenly, which leads to a wobbly, unusable pan.
12:04 supports Hannah of America's Test Kitchen Buy It For Life Enthusiasts
This is a beautiful pan. It's one of my, probably my most reached-for pan.

best in class Owns it Are Carbon Steel Pans Really The Best? | Gear Heads

Our buying, seasoning, and maintenance guide for every chef's secret weapon, the carbon steel skillet.
11:03 supports Hannah of America's Test Kitchen Buy It For Life Enthusiasts
You don't have to be careful with these pans. That's why I love them. I don't like to baby my pans. I don't like to make sure I'm using a certain spatula.

durability Owns it Are Carbon Steel Pans Really The Best? | Gear Heads

Cites scratch resistance, repairability

I have my pan here from home. This is little Eddie. Eddie and I have gotten in a lot of fights over the years, and we always make up.
3:31 supports Tom's Kitchen Cookware Reviewer
personally i think everybody should start off with cast iron

recommendation Owns it Cast Iron Vs Carbon Steel Vs Stainless Steel | Which Skillet Should You Buy?

Cites size and capacity, versatility

i highly recommend for all the skillets in this video to at least get 10 inches or larger preferably 12 inch skillets because 12 inch skillets are literally the jack of all trade skillets you can feed a family in a 12 inch skillet
i feel like once you got a cast iron skillet your next logical step is to upgrade to a carbon steel skill
i feel like every kitchen should have at least one stainless steel skillet if you can afford it
4:39 objects Prudent Reviews Cookware Reviewer
Acidic foods can degrade the seasoning and react with the metal. And boiling water for longer than a few minutes can also release the seasoning.

durability Tested it Stainless Steel vs. Cast Iron Cookware: 7 Key Differences & When to Use Each

Cites acid resistance (against), maintenance (against), rust resistance (against), seasoning durability (against)

Cast iron reacts with acidic foods like tomato sauce, citrus fruit, wine, and vinegar. It’s also prone to rusting if you don’t dry it thoroughly after cleaning. Because of that, you need to periodically season your cast iron pan.

How do skillets score among home cooks?

Computed only from claims about skillets by people we have grounds to call home cooks, so the axes answer “according to home cooks” rather than “according to everyone”.

Domain authority

1 recommender, weighted by demonstrated expertise in skillets. Weighted by expertise in this category, never by audience size.

Independent consensus

1 independent voice across 1 source. How many independent voices converge, unweighted.

Long-term ownership

no dated ownership reports yet. Volume and length of dated first-hand ownership reports.

Performance

3 performance claims. Claims about how well it does the job.

Value

no value claims yet. Claims about what it costs relative to what it does.

Repairability

no repairability claims yet. Claims about whether it can be maintained or rebuilt.

Community breadth

all evidence from a single community so far. How many distinct communities converge, rather than one echo chamber.

Recency of evidence

most recent evidence from 2024. How recent the evidence is. Old evidence is not wrong, just older.

Objections raised

3 negative claims, mostly ergonomics and aesthetics. How much complaint is on the record. A high figure means the drawbacks have been stated and quoted, not that the thing is worse.

These are separate measurements, not components of a score. They are never added together, and there is no overall rating, because which of them matters depends on what you are buying the thing for. An axis that says no evidence means nobody has spoken about it, not that the answer is low.